Analyzing Preference Drift: Changing Taste in Games

By MARK WILSON

playing cards

It’s important to know your own tastes in any creative field where you spend a lot of time. If I’m playing 200+ board games per year, and dozens of new-to-me titles, it behooves me to understand my preferences quite granularly. To do so is to save a lot of time and money, and create a lot more joy in the long-term.

Observation and reflection are at the core here. It’s not always positive, mind you. Reflection can sometimes cause us to nit-pick a game that we had quite a lot of fun with initially, and it’s only when thinking more about it that it sours. I believe this is sometimes post-rationalization that we do, to ensure that the identity we’ve carved out for ourselves internally (i.e. “I dislike {X} type of game!”) isn’t challenged overmuch.

I try to avoid this, and rather ruminate on what worked for me in the moment, or not. And why. This can change over time, as we play more games.

And so this article includes two goals, one more banal than the other:

  1. How my tastes have changed (the less interesting part)
  2. How we can all better observe and reflect on our experiences to come to accurate conclusions about how to create the most joy for ourselves and those around us.

A surface-level analysis of past reviews can identify several individual cases of drift:

Other, more minor occurrences of drift could be mentioned, but that’s the most portentous subset.

These on their own don’t say much. The underlying reasons for them, though, start to work us toward something that’s a bit more interesting:

  • I have gravitated away from games with marginal or sometimes even moderate interaction, in favor of those with higher levels of mechanical or social interaction. This has hurt the Stonemaier games mentioned above.
  • I came into “hobby” gaming around 2014, and this informed a lot of what I was exposed to at the time. It wasn’t until later that I started to discover entire wings of hobby gaming that provided meaningful juxtaposition to those earliest games.
  • I’ve simply played more games, period, at this point, and so I have more context for a lot of games and have occasionally discovered better games for me within particular genres.
  • I have a greater appreciation for simple silliness that doesn’t possess much strategy (see: Diamant). Some combination of working full-time + earning a Masters degree as a full-time student + COVID broke me around 2019-2021, and when I emerged on the other side, games with 20-30 minute teaches felt like insufferable work to me and I just wanted to smile and laugh.
  • As I play favorites more and more, occasionally they’ll start to trend downward. Not usually, mind you. But even with a fairly high threshold for reviewing on my site here (technically 3+ sessions, but in practice usually 10+), occasionally your first 3-10 sessions are your best, and you only start to see some of the cracks in the facade past this point. This is what happened with Treasure Island. This is frankly a point that a lot of reviewers never get to, particularly those focused on the latest releases. It’s an open secret that many popular reviewers aren’t playing more than 2-3 times before they make videos and promotions for a game.

This is better, but still isn’t quite where I want to get to, which is overarching takeaways that are generalized so that they’re not specific to me.

Life is change. My partner refers to life in “seasons.” Not literal seasons, but in terms of progressing from one state to the next that can sometimes be quantified into discrete segments. I like this analogy.

Some preferences will stick with you for life. But to deny all preference drift is likely to deny the evolution of ourselves as individuals. None of us are aware of the totality of possible experience, and so our current conceptions of life can be changed or refined to better actualize our internal and external goals.

This is loftier stuff than taste in toys, but to deny that there isn’t a connection from the lofty to the less important is to deny how our lives are an integrated whole, not separate chunks of experience. And again, if you spend a lot of time on a hobby, it pays to reflect on it.

So what types of things can change in our lives that can alter what we prefer:

  1. Who we play with
  2. Where we live
  3. The time we have to devote to gaming
  4. The number and breadth of games we’ve played
  5. Our changing relationship with enjoying “new” gaming experiences vs. enjoying the feeling of sinking more deeply into preexisting favorites.

This is a partial, incomplete list. But it’s a start in terms of reflection, and is part of what I try to do.

The Hard Part of Reflection

I think a lot of good habits in life – the ones that lead to better long-term outcomes in our lives – start with some brutal honesty with ourselves.

I emphasize “brutal” because it’s often not easy to make changes. We’re very good at rationalizing what’s become habitual for us.

Particular to games, this can include tastes in games, the collection that we keep, and the amount of time we spend focusing on a hobby when other, better endeavors may await.

I’m also convinced that the best games for us are at the intersection of a few things:

  1. What we personally love
  2. Games those we play with also love
  3. What we’re able to consistently get played

Basically, some game that could theoretically be as good as an existing favorite, isn’t, because it’s our continued commitment to playing and enjoying a game that is a very real aspect of our enjoyment, not just the game itself.

And so this is why I cull games from my collection somewhat liberally, even ones I quite enjoy. An element of enjoyment for me is the actualization of play on a consistent basis

So too with reviews. With some, I played them 3-10 times in short order, reviewed it, and then I haven’t played it since. Are they still good? Yes, undoubtedly. But the fact that they didn’t call back to me since that time, demanding to be tabled again, is somewhat telling. If I were to review some games again now, all of the technical aspects of the review would be similar. But I might soften my praise a bit, just because the game apparently didn’t have that ephemeral something that pulls it to my table regularly like some others have done in the intervening years.

Others would receive even more praise, though, for the same reason: they’ve survived the waves of change, both in the number of games I’ve been exposed to and my subtly shifting preferences. If it remains a game I play regularly, something is happening in it that goes beyond others I initially gave similar praise to.

This is the trickier aspect to reflect on, because nothing about my opinion of less-played games has changed in a technical sense. But it’s slid backward into an impossibly large pile of “Good” games that I never truly need to play again.

This is the trap of a lot of reviewing. The moment of review, when a game is fresh in our minds and so is our excitement from recent plays, paints a subtly flawed picture of many reviewers’ actual relationship with those games, and how they last (or don’t) on our tables.

Even when a lot of my reviews are written after playing a game across several years (again, I don’t chase new releases; screw that consumerist hype), I can point to some where this is the case. And it’s tautologically the case for those who are covering far more games than me per year and also cataloguing a lot more new releases. The vast majority of these – even the ones with glowing reviews – are not seeing the table past the review window for them.

In my opinion it’s worth thinking about even if you aren’t a reviewer. Sometimes the stories we tell ourselves don’t match with reality, and it can only be a good thing to dig into where those discrepancies are and which is the truer version of things.

…

Like my content and want more? Check out my other reviews and game musings!

Read More From BTD